TreinTramBus chairman Peter Meukens questions the Belgian Government‘s decision to introduce a road vignette while cooperation between the country’s different public transport operators remains difficult. In an opinion piece published in PV Magazine, Meukens argues that the policy runs counter to the government’s stated ambition to encourage a shift from cars to public transport.
From 1 May 2027, Belgium‘s three regions are due to introduce a road vignette for passenger cars and light commercial vehicles travelling on Belgian roads. Meukens finds the contrast with public transport striking.
“It is surreal that Belgium is taking this decision,” he writes. “Because if you read the Flemish coalition agreement of September 2024, it says the following about this: ‘A well-functioning mobility system is crucial for the Flemish economy. The impact of transport on climate and the environment is great.’”
The coalition agreement also states that infrastructure investments should contribute to the modal shift and that Flanders wants to maintain a high level of investment in public transport. Meukens therefore questions the logic of introducing a road charge without making comparable efforts to create an integrated public transport system.
“Flanders is thus striving for a modal shift. At least, that is what it claims,” he writes.
More traffic jams despite the modal shift ambition
Meukens points to figures from a study by SD Worx, published on 2 September 2026, which examined commuting behaviour among 16,000 employees in 16 European countries. Belgian employees spend an average of 48 minutes travelling to and from work each day, according to the study.
“Belgium is a topper, because here it is an average of 51 minutes,” Meukens writes. “The Belgian traffic jam problem is therefore only partly explained by the number of cars. In Flanders in particular, it is largely a matter of commuting.”
He also points to the evolution of congestion. In 2019, Flemish motorists faced around 750 kilometres of traffic jams on an average weekday. “Today that figure is 900 kilometres, 20% higher,” he writes. “Clearly, things are not getting better; if anything, they are getting worse.”
That leaves Meukens questioning whether a road vignette is an effective tool for achieving the government’s climate and mobility objectives.
“Flanders is thus striving for a modal shift. At least, that is what it claims,” he repeats.
Road vignette instead of kilometre charge
Meukens contrasts the planned vignette with the kilometre-based charging system that has previously been discussed in Belgium. He recalls that former Flemish Mobility Minister Ben Weyts (N-VA) defended a road vignette in 2018, after Germany considered introducing one.
According to Meukens, Weyts then criticised the German proposal as a “stupid levy”. Eight years later, Meukens sees a striking reversal.
“Now, in the overheated summer of 2026 in which everyone should be aware that climate change is dramatic, the minister may be forgiven for forgetting,” he writes. “Suddenly, the introduction of a road vignette is sold as a sign of insight and courage.”
Meukens adds that a road vignette would make foreign motorists contribute to Belgian road infrastructure, but questions whether this fits with the stated objective of reducing car use.
“If you want to achieve a modal shift and the intended climate objectives, isn’t a kilometre charge a better idea?” he asks.
He notes that the Flemish Government has rejected that approach, arguing that a kilometre charge would push Flemish motorists out of their cars. Meukens responds that this is precisely the point if the aim is to reduce car dependency — particularly during the commuting peaks.
Public transport still divided between operators
The TreinTramBus chairman then turns to what he sees as the bigger problem: the lack of integration between public transport operators.
One example is the cancellation of a bus service where a train already runs along the same route. Meukens refers to the situation between Aarschot and Leuven, where bus service 32a has been cut back since 1 July.
“If a bus line is abolished because a train also runs along the same route, you cannot make it impossible for travellers to suddenly have to buy two tickets,” he writes.
The problem, he argues, is not simply the loss of a bus connection. Passengers are being forced to make separate arrangements with different operators rather than being offered a genuinely integrated service.
“In Germany, Austria, and Switzerland, this is not strange: there, public transport is organised – sometimes not even by the state – in transport associations in which fare integration is established,” Meukens writes. “Bahn und Bus aus einem Guss.”
Germany, he adds, is already working on a short-term solution to provide tickets that can be used across different modes of transport.
“Why can cooperation work for roads, but not public transport?”
Meukens argues that Belgium’s institutional structure should not be used as an excuse.
“Federal Mobility Minister Jean-Luc Crucke (MR) is working on this,” he writes. “But he is facing the stubbornness of Flemish Mobility Minister Annick De Ridder (N-VA).”
He refers to the Flemish coalition agreement’s ambition to make public transport more attractive by making De Lijn‘s ticketing and fare integration work with other public transport operators.
“Putting the different public transport operators together is not a matter of political impossibility,” Meukens argues. “It is simply a question of cooperation between the different regions and the federal level.”
He also warns that without such integration, passengers can end up paying more simply because they cross an institutional boundary.
“If a bus line is abolished while a train also runs along the same route, you cannot make it impossible for passengers to suddenly have to buy two tickets,” he writes.
That can undermine the very modal shift that the government says it wants to achieve.
“Expensive and above all unnecessary,” Meukens writes of forcing passengers to choose another operator when an integrated ticket could be offered. “A traveller who has to switch to another mode of transport wants to know that it works, rather than having to find out that one plus one equals more than two.”
His central question is therefore also the title of the opinion piece: “Why can cooperation work for the road in Belgium, but not for public transport?”
Meukens concludes that Belgium already has an example of successful cooperation in the road sector, and argues that public transport should be treated in the same way: as one integrated system rather than a collection of separate operators.
The piece is an opinion article by Peter Meukens, chairman of TreinTramBus; the arguments and characterisations above are therefore presented as his views.
