Many gay men who are open about their sexuality still struggle to feel they belong within the mainstream gay community, according to a new survey – ‘Gay, but Not Gay Enough?‘ – published by Brendan O’Hara, founder of the Middle Men podcast and community. While the research is based on a small, self-selected sample rather than a representative population, it highlights a recurring theme of isolation among men who say they do not identify with the most visible aspects of gay social life.
O’Hara conducted the anonymous survey as part of Middle Men, an online community aimed at men who “don’t fit neatly into society’s straight or gay boxes“. In an accompanying article, he argues that coming out does not necessarily lead to finding a sense of belonging, particularly for men whose interests, values or lifestyles differ from what they perceive as mainstream gay culture.
The survey’s section on gay and queer respondents included just 24 participants, while broader questions attracted between 85 and 89 responses. O’Hara explicitly states that the results should not be generalised to all gay men because respondents were self-selected from people already engaging with Middle Men content. Instead, he presents the findings as a snapshot of the men his project is attracting.
Despite those limitations, the responses paint a consistent picture.
Only one of the 24 gay respondents said he felt “very at home” in the mainstream gay community. Nearly half (45.8%) said they did not really feel they fitted into the mainstream gay scene, while a further 25% felt only partly connected. Another 12.5% said they actively avoided the gay scene because they felt it did not represent them.
The findings also suggest that this sense of disconnection is not primarily linked to remaining closeted. Nearly 70% of respondents said they were either fully out or out to most people in their lives. More than half (54.2%) said they were comfortable being out, but did not see being gay as a central part of their identity.
Social networks reflected a similar pattern. Only 16.7% said most of their close friends were gay. More than half reported either being largely isolated from gay social life or having no gay social connections at all.
Different interests rather than uncertainty
Respondents were also asked why they did not feel fully at home within the mainstream gay community.
The most common reasons were differences in interests and lifestyle rather than discomfort with being gay itself. Almost three-quarters (72.7%) said they did not connect with nightlife, bar or club culture, while 68.2% felt their hobbies, interests or values were too different. Half believed the scene placed too much emphasis on youth and appearance, while more than a third said they did not identify with labels or identity politics. Others mentioned political or religious differences, racial representation or simply not feeling welcome.
Written comments echoed those themes.
Several respondents said they wanted communities built around shared interests rather than sexuality alone. Others described wanting spaces centred on hiking, sport, travel or emotional connection rather than sex, while one participant said simply: “Being gay is just one aspect of my life. It shouldn’t be all-consuming.”
Isolation extends beyond the gay community
The broader survey suggests these feelings are not confined to gay respondents.
Across 89 participants from different sexual identities, 72.4% said they had felt they belonged in neither the straight nor the gay world. Around two-thirds said their sexuality felt more complex than available labels could describe, while similar proportions reported loneliness, shame, fear of disclosure or wishing they had someone who truly understood them. Nearly nine in ten respondents said they had, at some point, felt like “the lonely only“, believing they were the only person experiencing attraction or identity in the way they did.
More than two-thirds also said navigating their sexuality, uncertainty or lack of belonging had affected their mental health to some degree. O’Hara stresses that the survey cannot establish cause and effect, but argues the responses suggest many respondents are carrying deeper feelings of isolation than simply preferring different social activities.
Existing research points to “intraminority stress”
O’Hara places his findings alongside existing academic research.
He highlights work by Yale researcher John Pachankis and colleagues, who developed the concept of “intraminority gay community stress“. Their research identified four recurring sources of stress within gay communities: emphasis on sex, status, competition and the exclusion of people who do not fit dominant ideals of appearance, masculinity, race or wealth. The researchers found these factors predicted poorer mental health even after accounting for discrimination from wider society.
The article also cites Australian research on masculinity among gay men and a 2024 qualitative study in which some participants described LGBTQIA+ communities as places of acceptance while others felt pressured to conform to expectations surrounding nightlife, appearance, sex and social behaviour.
More kinds of community
Rather than criticising established LGBTQIA+ communities, O’Hara argues there is room for additional spaces that appeal to different kinds of gay and bisexual men.
He says many respondents appear to be looking for friendships based on shared interests, values and personal growth, with sexuality remaining an important part of life but not the defining feature of every social interaction.
The article concludes that coming out and finding community are not always the same experience. According to O’Hara, some men find belonging immediately after coming out, while others continue searching for a place where they feel accepted as their complete selves. Middle Men, he says, aims to provide one such space rather than replace existing gay communities.
A Belgian perspective
I have no idea why Instagram decided to show me the accompanying post about this survey, but I’m glad it did because I found it genuinely interesting.
That said, I think there are a few important caveats.
An American perspective on a universal question
First, it feels very American. The United States is a huge and incredibly diverse country: urban, suburban, rural; progressive and conservative; wealthy and poor; coastal and inland. Experiences of being gay can vary enormously depending on where you live.
Belgium, by comparison, is tiny, roughly the size of Maryland, for any American readers.
As for me, I’m a 45-year-old, middle-class, cisgender gay man living in the centre of Antwerp, Belgium’s second-largest city, with around 500,000 inhabitants. I’ve spent most of my adult life single. Nowadays I’m perfectly happy with that. I don’t long for a boyfriend simply for the sake of having one, and I haven’t for quite some time.
I’m certainly not a scene queen, yet almost all of my friends are gay or bisexual.
Growing up in Belgium’s LGBTQIA+ youth movement
That is largely because I grew up in Belgium’s LGBTQIA+ youth movement. I started going to Antwerp’s youth group Enig Verschil. At the time there were many similar groups across Flanders. They were, and many still are, grassroots, volunteer-run organisations, accessible to everyone but with a membership that was largely middle class and made up of students or young professionals.
Originally there was an age limit of 26, later increased to 30 as it became harder to persuade younger people to take on organisational responsibilities.
I don’t really have a fixed friendship group or clique like you see in ‘Friends‘ or other TV shows. I’m more of a freelance friend.
But put it this way: the vast majority of the people in my contacts list didn’t come from school, college or university. They came from my years at Enig Verschil, from visiting similar LGBTQIA+ youth groups in other Flemish cities, and, more recently, from the internet.
What did we actually do? We met up. We organised educational activities, social events and fundraisers. We threw parties. Yes, relationships formed and people hooked up – mostly the guys – but because the groups were a genuine mix of gay, lesbian, bisexual and, at the time, a small number of trans members, it all felt remarkably ordinary. Sex happened, of course, but outside the formal activities of the youth groups.
Before the gay scene came the holebifuif
I also partied. But those parties were mostly what we in Flanders call a ‘fuif‘.
A ‘fuif’ (plural: ‘fuiven‘) is a distinctly Flemish phenomenon without a perfect English equivalent. It’s best described as a large, informal community dance party that combines elements of a nightclub, a school dance and a local festival. They’re organised by volunteers from youth organisations, sports clubs, student associations or other local groups, usually as fundraisers. They’re held in temporary venues such as community halls, sports centres or marquees, with affordable drinks, DJs and an emphasis on accessibility rather than exclusivity. They are about having fun with your friends, not about status.
So my early social life was, for want of a better word, very vanilla. The fuiven I attended were for LGBTQIA+ people, Back then we used the word âholebiâ, homo, lesbian, and bisexual.
My own journey through gay nightlife
Over time I did start going to gay clubs and discotheques. My peak clubbing years were around 2003 to 2005, more than twenty years ago now. But I never really “graduated” to circuit parties or gay cruises. The last time I went to La DĂŠmence in Brussels was well over fifteen years ago.
My first experience of a darkroom or playroom wasn’t until 2017, when I was already 36 years old. It happened in Taipei, Taiwan, at Commander D.
The paradox of Darklands
I’ve also been to Darklands (now: Beyond Darklands) three or four times. Kink and fetish are definitely not my natural habitat, so I’m really just a visitor there. Yet, ironically, nowhere else have I experienced gay people being so accepting. There was no body shaming, no kink shaming and very little judgement. Despite being an undeniably hypersexual environment, Darklands has been one of the most welcoming and inclusive gay spaces I’ve ever encountered.
The danger of reducing the gay world to “the scene”
So why am I writing all this?
Reading the comments beneath the Middle Men Instagram post, and, more generally, spending time on Instagram and the engagement- and outrage-driven world of Threads, I keep seeing the same complaints about “the gay scene”.
One thing I appreciate enormously is that Brendan O’Hara himself largely avoids those laments. That is both admirable and important. Others don’t, and I respect that their experiences are real.
But I do find it sad that so many people seem to reduce “the gay scene”, “the queer community” or “the LGBTQIA+ community” to nightlife, and often specifically to circuit parties full of young, muscular, Instagram-perfect men.
I’m not one of those men either. And honestly, I probably wouldn’t enjoy those events very much. With my decidedly non-Instagrammable body, I know I’m unlikely to “score” there.
But that’s only one tiny corner of an incredibly diverse world.
Instead, I read endless frustration. People blaming young people, older people, beauty standards, identity politics, contemporary terminology, sex, hookup culture… almost everything.
We shape our own spaces
One commenter, Gary (The Mayor 614), put it rather well: “Then get out and change the dynamic!!! Queer spaces are what we’ve built and allowed them to be. Always have been. We can change that any time we want. Y’all need to stop giving a damn what the ‘mean girls’ think. Bring your authentic self to queer spaces. Don’t play a role or a character because you think that’s what being queer means. That just feeds into the existing dynamic.”
I’m not sure I agree with every sentence of that, but I think there’s an important truth in it.
There is no single gay community
The rainbow – I’m deliberately avoiding the word “community”, because sometimes we are one and often we aren’t – is astonishingly diverse. Even if you only look at cisgender gay men.
Forget, for a moment, debates about gender identity or expression if those are the issues that divide people.
There are bars, yes. There are bathhouses, cruising venues and sex clubs.
But there are also sports clubs, hiking groups, choirs, book clubs, board-game nights, theatre companies, volunteer organisations, political groups, travel groups, charities and countless other ways to meet gay men where sex simply isn’t the point.
Those spaces exist.
Finding your own tribe
Of course, it’s much harder if you live in a rural area. In some places it may feel almost impossible. Geography matters.
But we’re also living in an age where finding people online has never been easier. Sometimes your local tribe doesn’t exist, but your online one does.
Finding your people takes openness, patience, curiosity and, perhaps, a willingness to let go of some of the frustration and preconceived ideas about what “the gay community” is supposed to be.
I know that’s much easier said than done.
But I also think it’s worth remembering that there has never been just one way to be gay.
Gay adventures of the homosexual kind
- RHINELAND-PALATINATE | Kurioos and Queer Koblenz.
- THAILAND | Gay Bangkok ft many male to male massages.
- HOW TO | Solo in Tokyo, Japan.
- GAY TOKYO | 24 Kaikan in Asakusa (+ Ueno and Shinjuku).
- GAY SEOUL | Jongno 3-ga ft. Bar MoU.
- GAY ITAEWON | Homo Hill = Usadan-ro 12-gil (ě°ěŹë¨ëĄ12길) in Seoul, South Korea.
- The best cities for gay cruising? London, Berlin, Paris, Madrid and Barcelona.
- QUEER KOREA | Beomil-ro, Busanâs gay street.
- GRAN CANARIA | 11 takeaways to enjoy Winter Pride Maspalomas to the fullest.
- The best cities to visit as a gay solo traveller.
- Gay Hong Kong.
- Heading for the sun in gay destination Torremolinos.
- QUEER ANDORRA | Entre Nous, the only gay bar in the village.
- Queer Iceland & Rainbow(baiting) ReykjavĂk.
- Manchesterâs gaybourhood around Canal Street.
- Pride in Valladolid, YucatĂĄn and queer encounters in Mexico.
- FLORIDA SOLO ROAD TRIP | Eye-opening encounters in Miami.
- FLORIDA SOLO ROAD TRIP | Fort Lauderdale.
- Drag queen bingo at Pride of our Footscray Community Bar.
- LGBTQ+ get-together on Majestic Princess.
- Gays failing at being gay? âLGBTQ Mix & Mingleâ on Royal Caribbeanâs Serenade of the Seas lacked enthusiasm.
- Gay Tel Aviv: pinkwashing or genuine?.
- Gay Taipei with misterb&b.

17 thoughts on “Why some gay men donât feel âgay enoughâ”
Mentions